First off , props on the extraction i think it was very well done. now to the
background, that mountain gives the whole wallpaper some depth that's good but
its too empty, also i do think too that the "water" looks more like
sand. the moon is alright i guess, but i dont like the stars, since the moon
shines so hard it'd actually be more difficult to see such bright stars near the
moon.
also, is she a magical girl? that'd explain why shes floating above water, im
not sure why she's floating above water, but heh i think all those erm, fairy
dust thingies and whatsoever suggest taht she has magical powers of some
sort.
this wall is just okay but far from decent despite my "nice"
criticism. the details you talked about didnt occure to me and to be really
honest and to stand against those overly nice comments you get from the other
members, this wall shouldnt be in the favs in my honest opinion.
Quote by eunasahngbakuretsu tenshi
walls are getting popular isn't it?
awesome wallpaper as usual sem-chan!
btw, have fun on your vacation (<-- saying it before i forget)
i luv your concept! it's all dark and red~ ^^
did you use stock for the buildings?
i simply luv the water....it's great - oh and the rocks too.
awesome wallie *fav*
heh i wonder why
neways, i dont see whats good on this wallpaper except for the scan extraction,
also the scan doesnt really fit in there. the cityscape is most probably pre-911
shots from new york, i dont see what effort you put in that wallpaper.
the starscape isnt nice at all. the stars are far to big, or better said, give
off a glow which is never possible but okay we're talking about a wallpaper
here, so neways, theres way too many stars up there. the shiny stuff on the
water...is overused..too much of it. the moon, wheres the glow around it? since
there is lightsource right behind it why doesnt have an outer glow from
that?
nothing special to me about this wallpaper, doesnt deserve a fav, imho.
Quote by ShiNN84If it is crap then why
are you submitting it? It's contradictory. Quit being an hypocrit at
least....
i second that, gawd why did you s**t out this wallpaper in one hour? wheres the
effort? and you even get 37 favs for NO WORK AT ALL. at least i dont see ne
effort in this one according to your comments.
this wallpaper would look nice if the character wouldnt be as grainy as the
background well it looks nice but its far to grainy even if you did that on
purpose =/ i like the text though but really the grainyness doesnt come good on
this wallpaper, but the colors are well chosen really lovely!
you wasted that scan for a bad background =/
well to be honest you didnt even care cleaning the scan and the background isnt
really what i call good. you slapped a very good scan/art on a
"crappy" (sry if its too harsh) background. i dunno how much effort
you put into it (probably alot since i can tell youre new at making wallpapers)
but for me thats not enough =/ its really sad to see this scan beeing used in
this background as you could have done much more out of it. i'm not telling you
im the better waller, i also dont have the intention to, im just telling you how
i feel about this wall and the scan. u might want to see my userpage. im using
part of my wallpaper in progress as design atm (use mozillas firefox to view the
userpage cause it looks much better in there)
i hope youll improve though, i wasnt better than you when i started off. making
a wall means more than just making a background and slapping an extracted
character on it. theres lots of work involved with it.
i will add you to my friendslist to see your latest walls and help you with
various things.
I second Shinn's last post from teh 1st word to the very last one...do you ppl
have eyes? maybe use them, or get contacts or glasses. one of the reasons why
really good walls dont get top favs is because of how ignorant the ppl sometimes
are. i didnt even dare read the first three pages cause i know it would have
been the same crap as on this last page, the only good criticism i read here was
from shinn.
Erm only thing i could rant about is how fscking pale renton looks either brom fscked up or you did something weird to him O_O is he a ghost
wave rider? i dun think so >< bring more vivid color to him only thing ill say :3 everything else is good, but not good enough to fav =/
nice fx (fractal flames???perhaps? ionno
tell me) in the background...nice finally something simplistic around. it has
lots of space for icons and some white style for windows, i must say i luv this
if i had a somewhat whitegrey/white style in windows id use this as wallpaper,
though i still have doubts that that character fits there...well the colors go
nice with her dress and the ribbons. but thats just me. bleh lol i'd probably
slapped some katana wielding character in there and some little sakura
leaves.
Text: 10
Background: 10
Scan: 10
Effects: 10
Firstview Rating: 8.0
overall a great wallpaper for a desktop with few or no icons which goes really
good with a white gui style.
Tama-Neko-Onee-Chan! You actually created the perfect wallpaper for windows xp's
erm olive theme the
colors would really fit in that style.
Well i cant say much but that you really did some good work on recreating the
rocks there. it looks nice and really has an easy feeling to it,
just...relaxing.
Also i am very impressed with the typography, should consider doing something
like that too =P in one of my next wallpapers.
well, you created a wall that gives me a calm feeling and still amazes me,
definite fav for you tama!
haha omg you just hit my taste...yes i might asume you drew riku by yourself
right? thats fantastic!
i really like th simplicity of this never thought somebody could make something
this simple! it all fits well, the typography is really great and thos blue
tones just hit my "add to fav" nerve =P blue is my color =D
thx for this wonderful minimalistic (positive ;P) wall its great!
A) Because I already did this character in one of my walls =p
b) The extraction is, excuse my harsh words, sucky =\ learn to use the lasso
and/or pen tool for better extraction, it ruins the whole thing =\
c) The moon looks to real, i bet you got that from a stock photo, try making
your own moon! theres lots of tutorials on the web. i suggest you go to www.solarvoyager.com ! theres tutorials
for planets, just adapt the settings to get a moon.
D) the water is....bleh i dun like it =\
e) the stars are...yeah okay, but not really what i would call a starscape =\
f) You might to want to take a look at my wallpaper with the very same character
on it AND it also has wings =3 what a coincidence! http://download.minitokyo.net/26959/
- "Angel of my Dreams"
hope i could help you a little bit with your wallpaper!
Hello einna-chan my darling ^_________________________________________^
nice wall you got there =3 its not overblown with effects and stuff and the
skyscape is really nice with those stars and the shooting stars =3 nehow nice
field you got there and nice swing xD
also the character is well extracted and implemented very good into the
background, great job einna *kissu*
Background: 8
- As I said really good work here, keep on working on it =3
Text: 10
- -
Scan: 10
- wellchosen and very good extraction and coloring!
Effects: 8.5
- Nice shooting stars and starsky!
first view rating: 6.5
- allthough good ratings above, it's not really blowing my brains out =3 but i
bet you'll be better the more you wall, just keep youre ideas going and going
and going and going!!!!
to the comments: omfg you ppl suck so uber bad what is this? a "crawl up my
fscking ass wallpaper - by semanga" or what? I don't think she really is
satisfied with crappy comments like "wow nice zomgzorzsZZDZazzt111elven
oneone+++!!!" at least i see some real good constructive comments, like
Wuschel's or Nekosasu's & co., maybe you ppl should take off yer eyes from
the damn boobs of teh gurl ppl use in their wallpapers and criticize (maybe i
spelled it wrong?) IT! give her suggestions on how to do things better, what
could have been done more, what really stciks out and what really was good!
Okay, I want to be honest with you =\ this wall has nothing special in it,
absolutely NOTHING. I'm just beeing honest and
stating the obvious I'm neither flaming nor am I trying to damage your
"reputation". I just want to say, put more effort in it, be honest!
How long did it take you to do that Wallpaper? It'd take me a mere ~30 min. or
even less! It's simplistic and I actually even like it somehow BUT , there's
much better wallpapers out there, which deserve the place your wallpapers on
now. do you know what i want to say?
okay here goes:
Scan: 4.5
- The scan is...not good but not bad. It looks enlarged and is just faded in to
the picture. big minus here. i think i know that scan is on mt somewhere, and im
more than sure you could have done more with it than that, but since you wanted
to keep it simple its okay though, just my standards are kind of high (even
though im a simplistic waller at times too, but this is what i want for a wall
in first place in the top favs to be)
Text: 6
- I really didnt know what to give here...so its just a six, i even considered
giving it a ten but then i just had to be honest and say to myself, "almost
all walls until this one had farely good typography/text" which means all
had a TEN in text ratings of mine. put more effort in here, you should know that
text/typography is really important in a wallpaper and even makes a really
crappy wall look somewhat good if its done right, but here it even pulls it
down. i think you want to know how to do it then right? well all i can say is i
learned myself how to make good typography, i have this feeling for it, look
other wallers wallpapers like sammo's, osi's or even mine to get a slight
imagination for how you could make better text next time!
Background: 8.5
- Simple starfield, never seen the use of that pinkish color before, a nice feel
to it and its like a breeze demo, that moon looks enlarged. if you made this off
of a tutorial you should make the beginning canvas bigger like 800*800 or even
1000*1000 or even higher. so when you decrease the size of the moon it wont look
so jagged and enlarged. the stars are good, unlike me who makes too many little
stars, you make like just enough to make it look subtle. so no complaints
here
First View Rating: 3
- this is the rating i give on the feeling i first get when i see a wallpaper =\
its not affected by above ratings. the above ratings are objective ratings
getting several elemnts out of a wallpaper and rating them to give a better
feedback. I just didnt get this "wow amazing art/work im stunned"
feeling which i get from other walls and which dont even hit the top favs. you
don't need to know the reasons why this is a three you know them already (i
stated them above already ^^")
heh good wall katz, nice to see someone walling negi =3 owww asunas uber hot. i
like the vector ^^ look really clean (duh) and the background looks....paperish?
also nice font there. did you make that pentagram yourself? i'd say you should
have taken a hexagram for that though =\
well here goes my rating's:
Background: 10
- no objections its simple and clean (Utada hikaru :3)
Scan/Vector: 15
- Great, i just love azuna first time i ever gave a 15 out of 10
Effects: 8.5
- Simple but good =3 like that pentagram and the paper? effect in the
background
Text: 10
- Yes the text is well placed and the font is well chosen!
First View Rating: 7.5
- allthough you have fairly good xD ratings on the elements of the wall this
didnt really have the uber something which makes me fav it ^^" BUT i dont
want ne noob walls to get to top fav and this not >) so this will get faved
dude
keep it up ^^" and dont forget some pantsu in your next wall ><
Sword this is brilliant... =D i like the background and yeah the characters rock
the background fits to the title. =D really nice background with that castle in
the background and the scan really fits too. good job here
bakground: 10
- The backgound is really nice. the smoke and the war like feeling really adds
to the mood
Scan: 10
- The scan is good extracted and really fits the title and the ambient in this
wall. good choice here
typography/text: 7.5
- I can't get friends with the text =\ it doesnt fit too good in it but thats
just me
Overall/First see rating: 8.0
- Yepp this is an eight for the skillz and the creativity =D you deserve it
hehe watch out for my wall...it will blast all MT records
the bacground is amazing O_O i could never be able to do something like that...
and... its amazing O_O how did you make the walls the broken windows...omg and
it all looks so perfect together ...the scan the background the text...its
perfect !
Background: 10
- Definitely a ten. nothing more to say really astounding work here
Effects: 10
- Giving here a ten too. I really can't see ne flwas in this wall...this is one
of THE best walls i've ever seen...
Typography: 9.5
- hey its a 9.5 but a DAMN good 9.5 for the text =D i dunno what to say
here...somethings missing...ill edit my post if i come to a conclusion...
Scan: 10
- the scan is spectacular, clean and really fits...and i like the girl damnit
i wanna watch that anime once
First View Feeling/Overall: 10
- DAMN straight!!! i gave it a ten after seeing if for only a second...this is
what this rating is about...its not the accumulation of the above ratings =)
youre the second one to make me give a ten in this rating...good job...now show
me your techniques
yes really good, keep it up i wanna fav this too =d
Hmm nice for a start =D the extraction was more or less okay...but i think the
scan is too bright O_o. the starfield looks great...but...a bit less stars?
cause in space i think you wouldnt see as many stars but thats just if im
looking at it from a more realistic view =P nice text/typography...all in all
fairly good for starters? (im not sure if you're new to walling). id suggest
you'd do something about momo beeing so erm...bright... maybe adjust
brightness/contrast or do something with the levels or so but if
it's your intention to make her that bright, make a smooth glow around her =D
just my opinion though..
kay that's it for now...im gonna keep track of your stuff ^^" so ill ady e
to my friendslist...
cats, laces, gurls, lingerie, sexappeal o_o"" haha this is
like real good fanservice ;P
he i like the background...its so zuri-chan like =D and good scan for this
one..it really fits and what i like most is that this wall is still subtle and
erm...humble?
neways here goes my ratings =D
Background: 10
- i fell in love with it the
colors interact so nicely...great job here
scan: 10
- hehe u know what lima likes ;
typogrpahy: 8
- he somethins wrong with the typo/text doesnt
fit IMHO
effects: 9.5
- hehe yeah the fx in the background are nice...as i said
overall feeling: 8
- yes i gave you lotsa tens nines and one eight...this is just the mark for my
very first impression of the wall and 8 is really good ;D only one person was
able to make me give a ten here ^^"
hehe so nice to see you again zuri-chan i missed your walls... ;D they're always
an inspiration and wohhooo ill ad this to my favs =D
hey sword! really nice composition and effects here =D its good...really
good....or at least much better than what i am capable of making atm Teh background doesnt stand out too much and its just .... WOW, nice
extraction nice effects =3 great typography... ha 8/10 points dude =d
- kay cya sword, and ill make sure to make a roxing wall again in future... =D
Again, another high quality work by you, tama-neko-chan , and
of course your vector is perfect! I like the celect, only thing i could rant
about is how many sparkly things you added and too many stars whatsoever but
that's not what is important to me in this wallpaper. the moon is my favourite,
the gradient from blueish to orangish xD is really nice and subtle.
yes, what makes this wall special is that it's made for dual screen, as you
said, and the contrast of both characters to each other with the colors is very
well done. blue is my favourite color so i kinda like the left side a bit more
but since teh gurls cute on the other side forgive
me =P
i hope to see more HQ stuff from you tama-neko! i'm really looking forward to it
=d
First off , props on the extraction i think it was very well done. now to the background, that mountain gives the whole wallpaper some depth that's good but its too empty, also i do think too that the "water" looks more like sand. the moon is alright i guess, but i dont like the stars, since the moon shines so hard it'd actually be more difficult to see such bright stars near the moon.
also, is she a magical girl? that'd explain why shes floating above water, im not sure why she's floating above water, but heh i think all those erm, fairy dust thingies and whatsoever suggest taht she has magical powers of some sort.
this wall is just okay but far from decent despite my "nice" criticism. the details you talked about didnt occure to me and to be really honest and to stand against those overly nice comments you get from the other members, this wall shouldnt be in the favs in my honest opinion.
- Limality
heh i wonder why
neways, i dont see whats good on this wallpaper except for the scan extraction, also the scan doesnt really fit in there. the cityscape is most probably pre-911 shots from new york, i dont see what effort you put in that wallpaper.
the starscape isnt nice at all. the stars are far to big, or better said, give off a glow which is never possible but okay we're talking about a wallpaper here, so neways, theres way too many stars up there. the shiny stuff on the water...is overused..too much of it. the moon, wheres the glow around it? since there is lightsource right behind it why doesnt have an outer glow from that?
nothing special to me about this wallpaper, doesnt deserve a fav, imho.
i second that, gawd why did you s**t out this wallpaper in one hour? wheres the effort? and you even get 37 favs for NO WORK AT ALL. at least i dont see ne effort in this one according to your comments.
this wallpaper would look nice if the character wouldnt be as grainy as the background
well it looks nice but its far to grainy even if you did that on
purpose =/ i like the text though but really the grainyness doesnt come good on
this wallpaper, but the colors are well chosen really lovely!
ahh this looks nice..and so...bloodish somehow
heh i
think i should use apophysis again sometime :3
you wasted that scan for a bad background =/
well to be honest you didnt even care cleaning the scan and the background isnt really what i call good. you slapped a very good scan/art on a "crappy" (sry if its too harsh) background. i dunno how much effort you put into it (probably alot since i can tell youre new at making wallpapers) but for me thats not enough =/ its really sad to see this scan beeing used in this background as you could have done much more out of it. i'm not telling you im the better waller, i also dont have the intention to, im just telling you how i feel about this wall and the scan. u might want to see my userpage. im using part of my wallpaper in progress as design atm (use mozillas firefox to view the userpage cause it looks much better in there)
i hope youll improve though, i wasnt better than you when i started off. making a wall means more than just making a background and slapping an extracted character on it. theres lots of work involved with it.
i will add you to my friendslist to see your latest walls and help you with various things.
sore dewa (well then in japanese :3), cya
I second Shinn's last post from teh 1st word to the very last one...do you ppl have eyes? maybe use them, or get contacts or glasses. one of the reasons why really good walls dont get top favs is because of how ignorant the ppl sometimes are. i didnt even dare read the first three pages cause i know it would have been the same crap as on this last page, the only good criticism i read here was from shinn.
period...
Erm only thing i could rant about is how fscking pale renton looks
either brom fscked up or you did something weird to him O_O is he a ghost
wave rider? i dun think so >< bring more vivid color to him 
only thing ill say :3 everything else is good, but not good enough to fav =/
hmm her right breast doesnt look as big as the left one =\ neways i like this
bleh you had to chose that pose ey =P (demands naked version xD jk
^_^")
hehe i wanna see more so keep it up...also coloring could be better but considering this your first its really good
nice fx (fractal flames???perhaps?
ionno
tell me) in the background...nice finally something simplistic around. it has
lots of space for icons and some white style for windows, i must say i luv this
if i had a somewhat whitegrey/white style in windows id use this as wallpaper,
though i still have doubts that that character fits there...well the colors go
nice with her dress and the ribbons. but thats just me. bleh lol i'd probably
slapped some katana wielding character in there and some little sakura
leaves.
Text: 10
Background: 10
Scan: 10
Effects: 10
Firstview Rating: 8.0
overall a great wallpaper for a desktop with few or no icons which goes really good with a white gui style.
+fav
lol now this is hilarious
great
job oracle =P haha yesh get roy sacked >< haha def +fav
O_O fred drew that for you???? haha cool neways, the coloring is great, its not too vivid since it looks so sketchy, overall great job!
Tama-Neko-Onee-Chan! You actually created the perfect wallpaper for windows xp's erm olive theme
the
colors would really fit in that style.
Well i cant say much but that you really did some good work on recreating the rocks there. it looks nice and really has an easy feeling to it, just...relaxing.
Also i am very impressed with the typography, should consider doing something like that too =P in one of my next wallpapers.
well, you created a wall that gives me a calm feeling and still amazes me, definite fav for you tama!
matane!
haha omg you just hit my taste...yes i might asume you drew riku by yourself right? thats fantastic!
i really like th simplicity of this never thought somebody could make something this simple! it all fits well, the typography is really great and thos blue tones just hit my "add to fav" nerve =P blue is my color =D
thx for this wonderful minimalistic (positive ;P) wall its great!
ja ne, lima
Hmm nice try but im not satisfied with this.
A) Because I already did this character in one of my walls =p
b) The extraction is, excuse my harsh words, sucky =\ learn to use the lasso and/or pen tool for better extraction, it ruins the whole thing =\
c) The moon looks to real, i bet you got that from a stock photo, try making your own moon! theres lots of tutorials on the web. i suggest you go to www.solarvoyager.com ! theres tutorials for planets, just adapt the settings to get a moon.
D) the water is....bleh i dun like it =\
e) the stars are...yeah okay, but not really what i would call a starscape =\
f) You might to want to take a look at my wallpaper with the very same character on it AND it also has wings =3 what a coincidence! http://download.minitokyo.net/26959/ - "Angel of my Dreams"
hope i could help you a little bit with your wallpaper!
Hello einna-chan my darling ^_________________________________________^
nice wall you got there =3 its not overblown with effects and stuff and the skyscape is really nice with those stars and the shooting stars =3 nehow nice field you got there and nice swing xD
also the character is well extracted and implemented very good into the background, great job einna *kissu*
Background: 8
- As I said really good work here, keep on working on it =3
Text: 10
- -
Scan: 10
- wellchosen and very good extraction and coloring!
Effects: 8.5
- Nice shooting stars and starsky!
first view rating: 6.5
- allthough good ratings above, it's not really blowing my brains out =3 but i bet you'll be better the more you wall, just keep youre ideas going and going and going and going!!!!
CYa!!!
to the comments: omfg you ppl suck so uber bad what is this? a "crawl up my fscking ass wallpaper - by semanga" or what? I don't think she really is satisfied with crappy comments like "wow nice zomgzorzsZZDZazzt111elven oneone+++!!!" at least i see some real good constructive comments, like Wuschel's or Nekosasu's & co., maybe you ppl should take off yer eyes from the damn boobs of teh gurl ppl use in their wallpapers and criticize (maybe i spelled it wrong?) IT! give her suggestions on how to do things better, what could have been done more, what really stciks out and what really was good!
damn assucrawlers
;;
================Critics hajimarimasu!================
Okay, I want to be honest with you =\ this wall has nothing special in it, absolutely
NOTHING. I'm just beeing honest and stating the obvious I'm neither flaming nor am I trying to damage your "reputation". I just want to say, put more effort in it, be honest! How long did it take you to do that Wallpaper? It'd take me a mere ~30 min. or even less! It's simplistic and I actually even like it somehow BUT , there's much better wallpapers out there, which deserve the place your wallpapers on now. do you know what i want to say?
okay here goes:
Scan: 4.5
- The scan is...not good but not bad. It looks enlarged and is just faded in to the picture. big minus here. i think i know that scan is on mt somewhere, and im more than sure you could have done more with it than that, but since you wanted to keep it simple its okay though, just my standards are kind of high (even though im a simplistic waller at times too, but this is what i want for a wall in first place in the top favs to be)
Text: 6
- I really didnt know what to give here...so its just a six, i even considered giving it a ten but then i just had to be honest and say to myself, "almost all walls until this one had farely good typography/text" which means all had a TEN in text ratings of mine. put more effort in here, you should know that text/typography is really important in a wallpaper and even makes a really crappy wall look somewhat good if its done right, but here it even pulls it down. i think you want to know how to do it then right? well all i can say is i learned myself how to make good typography, i have this feeling for it, look other wallers wallpapers like sammo's, osi's or even mine to get a slight imagination for how you could make better text next time!
Background: 8.5
- Simple starfield, never seen the use of that pinkish color before, a nice feel to it and its like a breeze demo, that moon looks enlarged. if you made this off of a tutorial you should make the beginning canvas bigger like 800*800 or even 1000*1000 or even higher. so when you decrease the size of the moon it wont look so jagged and enlarged. the stars are good, unlike me who makes too many little stars, you make like just enough to make it look subtle. so no complaints here
First View Rating: 3
- this is the rating i give on the feeling i first get when i see a wallpaper =\ its not affected by above ratings. the above ratings are objective ratings getting several elemnts out of a wallpaper and rating them to give a better feedback. I just didnt get this "wow amazing art/work im stunned" feeling which i get from other walls and which dont even hit the top favs. you don't need to know the reasons why this is a three you know them already (i stated them above already ^^")
kay that's my 100$
spend them well okay?
Lima
Hello Hello
heh good wall katz, nice to see someone walling negi =3 owww asunas uber hot. i like the vector ^^ look really clean (duh) and the background looks....paperish? also nice font there. did you make that pentagram yourself? i'd say you should have taken a hexagram for that though =\
well here goes my rating's:
Background: 10
first time i ever gave a 15 out of 10 
- no objections its simple and clean (Utada hikaru :3)
Scan/Vector: 15
- Great, i just love azuna
Effects: 8.5
- Simple but good =3 like that pentagram and the paper? effect in the background
Text: 10
- Yes the text is well placed and the font is well chosen!
First View Rating: 7.5
- allthough you have fairly good xD ratings on the elements of the wall this didnt really have the uber something which makes me fav it ^^" BUT i dont want ne noob walls to get to top fav and this not >) so this will get faved dude
keep it up ^^" and dont forget some pantsu in your next wall ><
Sword this is brilliant... =D i like the background and yeah the characters rock
the background fits to the title. =D really nice background with that castle in the background and the scan really fits too. good job here
bakground: 10
- The backgound is really nice. the smoke and the war like feeling really adds to the mood
Scan: 10
- The scan is good extracted and really fits the title and the ambient in this wall. good choice here
typography/text: 7.5
- I can't get friends with the text =\ it doesnt fit too good in it but thats just me
Overall/First see rating: 8.0
- Yepp this is an eight for the skillz and the creativity =D you deserve it
hehe watch out for my wall...it will blast all MT records
Oh my god...this is so nice =D
the bacground is amazing O_O i could never be able to do something like that... and... its amazing O_O how did you make the walls the broken windows...omg and it all looks so perfect together ...the scan the background the text...its perfect !
Background: 10
damnit
i wanna watch that anime once 
- Definitely a ten. nothing more to say really astounding work here
Effects: 10
- Giving here a ten too. I really can't see ne flwas in this wall...this is one of THE best walls i've ever seen...
Typography: 9.5
- hey its a 9.5 but a DAMN good 9.5 for the text =D i dunno what to say here...somethings missing...ill edit my post if i come to a conclusion...
Scan: 10
- the scan is spectacular, clean and really fits...and i like the girl
First View Feeling/Overall: 10
- DAMN straight!!! i gave it a ten after seeing if for only a second...this is what this rating is about...its not the accumulation of the above ratings =) youre the second one to make me give a ten in this rating...good job...now show me your techniques
yes really good, keep it up i wanna fav this too =d
- Limality
Hmm nice for a start =D the extraction was more or less okay...but i think the scan is too bright O_o. the starfield looks great...but...a bit less stars? cause in space i think you wouldnt see as many stars but thats just if im looking at it from a more realistic view =P nice text/typography...all in all fairly good for starters? (im not sure if you're new to walling). id suggest you'd do something about momo beeing so erm...bright... maybe adjust brightness/contrast or do something with the levels or so
but if
it's your intention to make her that bright, make a smooth glow around her =D
just my opinion though..
kay that's it for now...im gonna keep track of your stuff ^^" so ill ady e to my friendslist...
cats, laces, gurls, lingerie, sexappeal o_o"" haha
this is
like real good fanservice ;P
he i like the background...its so zuri-chan like =D and good scan for this one..it really fits and what i like most is that this wall is still subtle and erm...humble?
neways here goes my ratings =D
Background: 10
the
colors interact so nicely...great job here
u know what lima likes 
;
doesnt
fit IMHO
- i fell in love with it
scan: 10
- hehe
typogrpahy: 8
- he somethins wrong with the typo/text
effects: 9.5
- hehe yeah the fx in the background are nice...as i said
overall feeling: 8
- yes i gave you lotsa tens nines and one eight...this is just the mark for my very first impression of the wall and 8 is really good ;D only one person was able to make me give a ten here ^^"
hehe so nice to see you again zuri-chan i missed your walls... ;D they're always an inspiration and wohhooo ill ad this to my favs =D
hey sword! really nice composition and effects here =D its good...really good....or at least much better than what i am capable of making atm
Teh background doesnt stand out too much and its just .... WOW, nice
extraction nice effects =3 great typography... ha 8/10 points dude =d
- kay cya sword, and ill make sure to make a roxing wall again in future... =D
Again, another high quality work by you, tama-neko-chan
, and
of course your vector is perfect! I like the celect, only thing i could rant
about is how many sparkly things you added and too many stars whatsoever but
that's not what is important to me in this wallpaper. the moon is my favourite,
the gradient from blueish to orangish xD is really nice and subtle.
yes, what makes this wall special is that it's made for dual screen, as you said, and the contrast of both characters to each other with the colors is very well done. blue is my favourite color so i kinda like the left side a bit more but since teh gurls cute on the other side
forgive
me =P
i hope to see more HQ stuff from you tama-neko! i'm really looking forward to it =d
- Limality